The true wi-fi earbud revolution, which has solely not too long ago shifted into excessive gear, has been dominated by Apple’s AirPods. Despite displaying up late to the social gathering, they’re inexpensive and simpler to make use of than most rivals, most of which nonetheless haven’t lived as much as expectations. We hoped that Google would kickstart the social gathering by leaping into the fray with its personal true wi-fi buds, and provide Apple some actual competitors. But when Google lastly revealed its Pixel Buds, some air (no pun supposed) went out of the room.
Instead of providing totally wi-fi, impartial buds within the vein of Apple’s AirPods and Bragi’s The Headphone (amongst many others), the Pixel Buds come tethered along with a small wire like so many “wireless” buds earlier than them. Reliably connecting two thimble-sized devices by way of skinny air (and your cranium) has stumped many startups, and it appears even Google doesn’t but have an excellent answer.
Still, whereas they don’t compare directly to the AirPods, the Pixel Buds make a valiant (if flawed) first try at staking their very own floor, providing intuitive faucet controls and a few distinctive options to set them aside from the group, like real-time translation. In our Google Pixel Buds overview, we dig deep so you possibly can determine if the newest from massive G are the wi-fi earbuds you want in your vacation procuring listing.
Little gray field, massive black buds
The Pixel Buds arrive in a clear white field that reminded us of the packaging for Google’s first actual win, the Chromecast. Inside, a felt-covered gray field sits on a throne of Paper-Foam, that molded, soft-touch cardboard every thing appears to come back in lately. Beneath it you’ll discover directions in a number of languages, and a USB-C charging cable.
Google’s fabric case, concerning the dimension of a hoop field, seems to be completely different than most we’ve seen, however it’s much less elegant in design than Apple’s easy-flip capsule. Opening it through a tiny black flap takes nimble fingers. The Buds inside are bulbous discs linked to U-shaped earpieces, resting on magnetic cradles. They could be common sized for true wi-fi buds, however they’re monstrous for tethered ones. Along with our black pair, in addition they are available in white and blue.
The charging case is each an added bonus and a necessity.
The case’s fuzzy exterior feels good in your fingers, however the lid appears a little bit flimsy, as if it may be simply separated or crushed in your pocket. Winding the snazzy, braided cable to suit inside can also be one thing we’ve but to get used to. Google truly offers a GIF to show you the way, however the cable at all times needed to leap again out earlier than we snapped shut the lid.
A trio of LEDs contained in the case reveal battery life: A single dot lights up strong inexperienced when your buds are totally charged and flashes white when pairing, whereas all three glow white to disclose a completely charged case. Battery life is rated at 5 hours for the buds themselves and 24 hours with the case, mirroring precisely (you guessed it) Apple’s AirPods. Most tethered rivals at and even beneath the Pixel Buds’ $159 worth vary provide eight to 10 hours of playback, so the charging case is each an added bonus and a necessity. Fast charging offers you an hour of playback on a 10-minute cost.
While experiences could fluctuate, we discovered the Pixel Buds extra finicky to pair than most wi-fi earbuds, true or tethered. Like Apple’s AirPods (damaged document, we all know), they’re designed to auto-pair, however that didn’t play out as designed.
For Pixel phones, you’re instructed to easily open the case to pair. When we went to pair them to the Pixel 2, although, the buds didn’t present up within the Bluetooth menu. After some futzing with the pairing button (and restarting the cellphone) we lastly acquired them linked.
Google Pixel Buds Compared To
If you’re connecting something however a Pixel, Google’s directions level you to a helper site, which is a little bit convoluted. At the underside are directions for “Reconnecting” (tapping twice on the proper bud) which acquired us linked. Below which can be directions to carry the button contained in the case for guide pairing in its place. Why Google didn’t merely put a Bluetooth image on the practically invisible button is past us.
Purpose-built to sit down simply inside your ear canal, the Pixel Buds by no means fairly really feel safe. As Google promised, we largely acquired used to the match over time (and had zero points with them falling out), however it was odd every time we reinserted them. The free match additionally means little or no ambient noise isolation, so workplace chatter and airplane engines leak proper by way of. On the brilliant aspect, the adjustable braided cable is silky easy and barely registers in your neck.
A single faucet on the proper earbud will play and pause tracks whereas swiping ahead or backward controls quantity. Both labored completely, in sharp distinction to most comparable designs we’ve encountered. The undeniable fact that Google’s earbuds don’t totally seat in your ears could also be partly accountable: When earbuds dig into your ear canal, it’s uncomfortable to faucet too exhausting.
Interestingly, quantity isn’t one thing we needed to take care of a lot. That’s as a result of the Pixel Buds are about as loud as we ever wanted them at their lowest setting. Moving up greater than two notches was too loud for our ears, and every step up raised quantity greater than we’d like. You can modify quantity extra granularly straight on the Pixel 2, however we’d favor extra management on the buds.
Google clearly heard a few of our management issues, nevertheless, as the corporate has added extra choices through a firmware replace that started rolling out in May 2018. Song skipping, beforehand unavailable, is a welcome new inclusion to the tap-control arsenal. Originally, double tapping merely allowed you to listen to notifications as they arrived, however Android customers can now set it to skip to the subsequent observe by accessing the Pixel Buds beneath the Google Assistant app and enabling the choice within the settings. Meanwhile, triple tapping (historically the command for skipping again a observe) will energy down the Pixel Buds with the brand new rollout — although we’d nonetheless love a strategy to skip again.
In addition, Google has added a better strategy to transfer between beforehand paired units (equivalent to your cellphone and laptop), by merely choosing them out of your beforehand paired system. While this might not be a monumental change, issue in pairing has been amongst our points with the Pixel Buds, so we’re glad Google is engaged on it.
Google Assistant and prompt translation
An enormous draw for these earbuds is simple entry to Google Assistant. Tap and maintain the proper earbud to start out speaking to Assistant, and it’ll reply to instructions, supplying you with the climate or serving up instructions (your cellphone will detect if you happen to’re strolling and offer you strolling instructions). You can even place calls, skip songs, ship textual content messages, and management streaming companies — virtually something the Google Assistant can do on the cellphone is honest recreation with the Pixel Buds.
While many wi-fi earbuds provide comparable options for Google Assistant, Siri, or Samsung’s Bixby, Google’s Pixel Buds are easy in operation. There’s virtually zero delay between whenever you press and maintain on the proper earbud and when you can begin speaking, and responses are speedy too.
Julian Chokkattu/Digital Trends
Perhaps essentially the most thrilling function works in tandem with Assistant: Instant translation through Google Translate. Tap and maintain the proper earbud and say “help me speak Spanish,” or one of many 40 supported languages. On your Pixel 2 smartphone, you’ll see the Google Translate app open up however with a novel interface particularly when it detects the Pixel Buds are linked. Tap and maintain the proper earbud and say a phrase, and the smartphone will then communicate the phrase within the language you request. You’ll want to carry the cellphone in entrance of the individual you’re chatting with so that they hear the interpretation from the speaker.
Using Google Translate with the earbuds is fluid and simple, and could possibly be nice for touring.
The individual you’re chatting with can then faucet the icon on the display screen and say a phrase of their language, and also you’ll hear the translated sentence in your ear. We practiced with one in every of our multi-lingual colleagues, a local Spanish speaker from Colombia, and each of us had been impressed at how correct the interpretation was. Our colleague even tried to mess with the app by utilizing her area’s phrase for “cool,” chévere, and the app didn’t falter. The app additionally picked up the Mexican desire chido, with no hassle. In reality, we needed to work fairly exhausting to dig up an error, utilizing city-specific slang to throw it for a loop. Even correct names, like avenue names, labored higher than anticipated.
It’s probably not new, however utilizing the function with the earbuds is fluid and simple, and we might see it coming in helpful whereas touring. The app can nonetheless battle at occasions, however it’s an enormous step ahead on the trail to fluid dialog overseas.
The Pixel Buds will play audio from any Android cellphone operating Android 5.zero Lollipop or greater, and from iPhones operating iOS 10 and better. To make use of the Assistant, you’ll want an Android cellphone that’s operating Android 6.0 Marshmallow and better. If you need the moment translation function, you’ll should buy a Pixel 2 or Pixel 2 XL smartphone for now.
We’ve already seen some early reviewers rating the Pixel Buds among the many greatest wi-fi headphones they’ve heard. To them we are saying: It’s time to take a look at some extra wi-fi headphones. You can get quite a bit from a $100-to-$150 pair of Bluetooth buds lately, together with sound that far outshines what Google’s buds provide.
That stated, for the overwhelming majority of customers, the sound the Pixel Buds present will likely be simply superb. It’s not incredible, it’s not glowing, vibrant, current, or every other coveted buzzword audio reviewers pull from our bag of methods to get customers enthusiastic about nice sound. But it will get the job carried out, each for listening to music and for fielding cellphone calls, which come by way of clearly from each side.
Luckily, for these maintaining rating within the Android/iOS Battle Royale, the Pixel Buds don’t sound a lot worse (or higher), than Apple’s personal AirPods. They simply sound completely different. In quick, the desire between them will likely be based mostly on style. Both units of headphones are tuned to enchantment to — or no less than abstain from offending — the biggest variety of folks doable. But, the place Apple goals for a extra balanced and brighter contact, Google goes low (fairly actually) with a bass-forward sound signature that may enchantment to ears nursed on Beats and their bass-heavy ilk.
Kick and tom drums, bass guitar, and different decrease register devices make their presence identified in each observe, boosted properly above their placement within the studio combine, with out going full-on, bass-head bonkers. The result’s a sound that serves up some weight and fullness to your music, particularly down low, whereas leaving quite a bit to be desired on the subject of presence and definition within the higher registers. Midrange and treble-focused percussion will get the shortest finish of the stick, as snare drums and cymbals sound smeared and smoothed over in the meanwhile of impression, virtually as if each drummer has switched out their drumsticks for timpani mallets.
Bill Roberson/Digital Trends
That lack of sparkle within the center frequencies is shared elsewhere, too, obscuring presence and readability in every thing from the jangly brass of an acoustic guitar string to the whisper of a singer’s lips as she approaches the microphone for an intricate verse. The result’s a heat and virtually lazy sound that’s by no means off-putting, however hardly ever partaking.
Google’s Pixel Buds provide a restricted one-year warranty which applies solely to Pixel Buds bought within the U.S. or Canada.
Google’s Pixel Buds are a strong first entry on the planet of wi-fi earbuds, and for Pixel cellphone consumers, they supply some distinctive options which may be value consideration. At $159, nevertheless, they don’t provide the sort of options and efficiency we anticipate from buds linked by a cable.
Is there a greater different?
Apple’s $159 AirPods are any simple improve for anybody irritated by the Pixel Buds’ wire, particularly if you happen to personal an iPhone. Other strong wi-fi selections at or close to the Pixel Buds’ worth level embody The Headphone from Bragi at $149 (although it doesn’t include a charging case), and Jabra’s Elite Sport, that are totally waterproof and embody health monitoring for $200-250.
For each Android and iOS customers, there are a ton of nice selections within the tethered wi-fi earbuds market, a lot of which provide higher efficiency and extra options for lower than the Pixel Buds, with the caveat that they don’t include a charging case. V-Moda’s Forza Metallo Wireless are a fantastic selection for much less money, boasting killer sound, a safe match, and sweatproofing to take in your every day exercise. While not sweatproof, Shure’s similarly priced SE215 Wireless provide wonderful sound, and will also be plugged in for versatile use. If understanding is your predominant bag, you’ll need to take a look at Jabra’s Sport Pulse Wireless Special Edition, which provide sweatproofing and exercise options like a heart-rate monitor.
How lengthy will it final?
From the braided cable to the hard-plastic shells, Google’s Pixel Buds really feel properly constructed. That stated, the case’s slightly flimsy lid is of some concern, particularly for many who are exhausting on their gear.
Should you purchase it?
Unless you’re a Pixel cellphone proprietor who travels overseas frequently, we’d suggest wanting elsewhere. While the Google Translate function is cool, it’s not a lot better with the Pixel Buds than what you’ll get straight out of your cellphone, and except for prolonged battery life within the case, there simply aren’t sufficient extras right here to warrant the worth. We anticipate Google’s subsequent model to be totally wi-fi, which, if they’ll hold all of the options provided right here, ought to make them a extra critical competitor.
Update: Added data about new options rolling out. By Ryan Waniata